Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
smart142

A day behind the wheel of an electric vehicle

15 posts in this topic

By Megan Stacey, Woodstock Sentinel-Review

Thursday, January 14, 2016

The Sentinel-Review spent a day behind the wheel of an electric vehicle to see what it's really to drive and charge one. The day began at the Woodstock Hydro public charging station. The car left with a full battery, and set off for a journey around the county. Megan Stacey reports.

Sitting behind the wheel of a smart electric car felt a bit like climbing into a tree house.

It's cramped, but cute. For many environmentalists, the electric vehicle -- both the minuscule smart variety and the regular-sized versions -- is a dream come true. The ride is smooth, and there are no stops for gas. Those smelly, grey exhaust fumes are a thing of the past.

There's just one catch. Until charging stations become as ubiquitous as their gas counterparts, it can be tough for an electric vehicle (EV) owner to get around.

Without a place to "fuel up," journeys in an EV are limited to short jaunts - from home to work, or the office to the supermarket.

The province announced last month that $20 million earmarked for EV charging stations in Ontario will be up for grabs.

And Oxford wants in.

With a goal to use 100 per cent renewable energy by 2050, the region is looking at just how to get there. Jay Heaman, co-chair of Smart Energy Oxford and an EV owner, is hoping the region can capitalize on the provincial grant. He extolled the virtues of his little smart electric car during this day behind the wheel of an electric vehicle.

"When you have a combustion vehicle, it's only converting about 25 per cent of the energy to motion. They're so inefficient. Whereas an electric takes about 80 to 85 per cent of the energy, and it puts it right to the wheels," Heaman said.

"There's not too many cars that will touch an electric off the line," he said, hitting the gas on Norwich Avenue as the electric vehicle whizzed past pickup trucks and SUVs.

Between the car's teeny stature and its speed, it felt a little like something out of the future.

"Not too bad for a little dinky car, huh?" Heaman said.

Owners of these green, mean machines are a passionate bunch.

They believe the electric vehicle is at the forefront of a possible overhaul in the way humans go from point A to point B - a shakeup that could put a stop to current gas-guzzling ways.

Woodstock's Tesla supercharger station -- the first tour stop -- illustrates some of the industry's innovation.

One of the eight chargers outside the Quality Hotel on Juliana Street can give a Tesla -- luxury electric vehicles -- about 300 kilometres worth of battery power in half an hour.

Heaman said an average EV like his would pick up about 5 kilometres during 30 minutes of charging.

And the superchargers won't work on any EV, just a Tesla. The charging port for a Tesla is a specialized two-pronged hose, whereas Chevy Volts or smart electrics use a three-pronged one.

It's like trying to charge an Android cellphone with an Apple charger.

"We're stymied," Heaman said. "But in fairness to Tesla, they're the only car company selling an electric car that's really investing in charge stations."

Luckily, the supercharger station was just the first stop.

Battery life: 98 per cent.

But just a few hundred metres up the road, Woodstock's Best Western hotel boasts two chargers: one for standard EVs and two for Teslas.

"They're supposed to be for guests, but if it's dying, it's dying," said Lecia Gordon at the front desk. "I'd like to think that if I had one of those vehicles and it was dying, someone would give me a charge."

Heaman's EV charged for about five minutes during the conversation inside with Gordon.

Battery life hovered around 98 per cent.

The hotel's chargers are considered Level 2 (superchargers are Level 3, and a 120-volt outlet Level 1). Heaman said an hour's charge from a Level 2 charger would likely cost the business about 50 cents.

The hotel doesn't track EV drivers, Gordon said, so there's no way to prove how many are using the charger. Likely, one station is enough.

But it exposes a problem - the unpredictability of driving and charging an EV.

"If you show up and it's not working or someone's plugged in, you're out of luck," Heaman said.

The next stop was Gunn's Hill Artisan Cheese.

Owner and operator Shep Ysselstein said he rarely, if ever, sees customers come in an electric vehicle.

"I would notice because I'm interested in things like this. Once in a blue moon, I've seen a Tesla," he said.

Ysselstein even came outside to check out Heaman's smart electric and sit behind the wheel. He said he'd like to buy a Tesla when the company comes out with a more reasonably priced vehicle.

With a few blocks of cheese now in the car, the EV tour continued.

Battery life: about 90 per cent.

There were a few brief stops in Norwich and Otterville before the EV pulled into Tillsonburg.

Battery life was down around 40 per cent, and the hunt was on to find a charge.

"Any vibrant commercial core should have this," said Tillsonburg Mayor Stephen Molnar of charging stations.

"It 's about becoming a region ... are we connected as a county?" Molnar mentioned the downtown mall as a good candidate for a charging station, thanks to huge parking lots, a central location, and easy access to restaurants and shops to spend an hour while charging.

And it's clear there is interest in Tillsonburg.

Molnar said he knows of at least a few Chevy Volt owners, and even one resident with a Tesla.

But there are no public chargers yet.

To charge his car, Heaman turned to the last-ditch option. Any regular 120-volt outlet can be rigged up to the car's EV adaptor and used as a charging point. That system is best used for long stops, when a driver is at home or at the office.

"It's 20 hours (to fully charge) from zero," Heaman explained.

"In this car, at this time of year, you might get six or seven kilometres per kilowatt hour, so for every hour you're plugged in (to a 120 V outlet), you're only going to get maximum six or seven kilometres."

But the outlet outside the town's customer service centre didn't work. Heaman circled the nearby Canadian Tire and Metro to look for an external outlet.

No luck, although a Chevy Volt was spotted outside the grocery store.

As electric cars evolve, so too does the language. There's a specific term -- range anxiety -- to describe the worry that builds as an EV driver tries to make it to the next destination or charging station.

The EV journey in Heaman's vehicle makes one thing clear: a tourist in Oxford or an EV driver that left home without a full battery could easily find themselves stranded in parts of the county.

Heaman's EV was getting low by the time it reached Ingersoll's charging stations.

Battery life: 18 per cent.

The town has two options -- a charger at the Comfort Inn on Samnah Crescent and another outside the ERTH office on Whiting Street.

The public-private distinction is also a challenge in building EV infrastructure.

If businesses with a charging station allowed public access, the implications for drivers could be huge. The same goes for payper-use options on private property. Heaman said he'd be happy to pay for the comfort of knowing a charge would always be available.

After a day on the roads, and nearly 100 kilometres travelled, Heaman's car arrived back in Woodstock with about 10 kilometres left in the battery's life.

Though Oxford is positioning itself at the forefront of the EV movement, charging stations are still far from convenient.

More accessible stations would also help entice more drivers to think about transitioning to an EV, Heaman said.

He's hopeful that other municipalities in the region will try to attract some of that government funding.

"The idea is to try and create commitment."

http://www.woodstocksentinelreview.com/2016/01/14/a-day-behind-the-wheel-of-an-electric-vehicle

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've been to Gunn's Hill Artisan Cheese three or four times in my ED. Maybe next time instead of petting Bo, the resident dog, I'll look for Mr. Ysselstein. Considering they won a $100,000 award from the Business Development Bank, I guess he might just get that Tesla.

Also "Heaman said an average EV like his would pick up about 5 kilometres during 30 minutes of charging." My experience is that a 4.5 hour charge on L2 gives me about 109 km, which would be 12 kilometres during 30 minutes. Or was Mr. Heaman talking 120V?

I hope the mayor of Tillsonburg is able to get some public chargers downtown. That would be a welcome addition.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

For the moment ... Useless!

I am waiting for the Chevrolet Bolt, plus a little bit longer to see if the car actually lives up to its expectations, because that one - if it operates as claimed - will do my daily rounds without having to deal with (and wait for) public charging stations.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

For the moment ... Useless!

I am waiting for the Chevrolet Bolt, plus a little bit longer to see if the car actually lives up to its expectations, because that one - if it operates as claimed - will do my daily rounds without having to deal with (and wait for) public charging stations.

The Bolts 9 hour charge means it's Esther got a battery almost 70kw (sounds heavy for a small car) or a small charger ( they are afraid of damaging the batteries because they are not heated/cooled) I think they should have included a DC level 3 charger option

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The Bolts 9 hour charge means it's Esther got a battery almost 70kw (sounds heavy for a small car) or a small charger ( they are afraid of damaging the batteries because they are not heated/cooled) I think they should have included a DC level 3 charger option

Looks like you haven't read anything about the Bolt, look here for answers to your guesses:

http://www.mychevybolt.com/forum/search.php?search_id=active_topics

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm glad to see there is some form of fast charge available

All EV should charge at 100KW/h it's the only way people will stop complaining about the range.

Now we just need Saudi Arabia to stop running 97billion$$ deficits and get oil back over $120 a barrel and progress will happen

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm getting tired of reading reviews of EVs written by people who've never driven one before. All they can ever think about is range. :grrrr:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've met with Jay a few times. The first time was before Woodstock Hydro had the public stations installed, and they only had one station around back inside the service bay for their Leaf. Jay let me use it for my Smart ED and chatted with me for a while. I chatted with him again on a couple other occasions after the public chargers were installed, and then one day when picking up my Smart at the public station there was another one identical to mine parked behind it. Jay's business card was under my wiper and had a note written on it: "I followed your lead".

I assume he was misquoted in the article, he seems well informed and knowledgeable, not only about EVs but in renewable energy in general.

I think the low prices of oil came at good time, it means the EVs will be harder to sell, and those of us looking to buy will have a little more leverage at negotiation time.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm getting tired of reading reviews of EVs written by people who've never driven one before. All they can ever think about is range. :grrrr:

The compromises that current EV owners have to make, and which are evident in that article, aren't acceptable to normal people. They're certainly not acceptable to me. And ... it's all about range!

I know what my driving patterns are like; I don't have time to plan routes around charging stations (which may or may not be available or tied up) and I don't have time to wait for charging. Overnight charging is fine but it's gotta do the whole day's run without recharging.

Current EV owners can be considered early-adopters. Early-adopters tend to minimize the downsides of what they have to deal with ...

Bear in mind that the Chevrolet Bolt has my interest. It's not that I'm some sort of anti-EV crusader - far from it. But current EVs are either too expensive (Tesla) or unsuitable due to insufficient range combined with inadequate quick-charging availability.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sure, no one should buy an EV without knowing its shortcomings and range is probably paramount among them. But once you've accepted those limitations and have owned an EV you will find that range anxiety vanishes after the first week. It becomes a non-issue. The reviewer is overwhelmed by range even though, in the end, she didn't need to charge at all.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It only becomes a non-issue if your typical driving day takes you about 80 km or so. I would in theory like an electric too but I need 300 km of nominal range to be comfortable. The Bolt might be the ticket.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I cannot "accept" a 100 km range when the average workday (averaged over 1 year) covers 160 km and the outliers (~ 1% of the time) are about double that, and it's 160 km one way to my sister's place. It is not a matter of "accepting" anything. It simply isn't going to get the job done.

I have another gas powered vehicle that I'm willing to use on the 1% workdays and for vacations, which will always exceed any foreseeable EV range. It uses double the fuel that the gas smart uses.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The Bolt might do the job, once we see its EPA figures. GM is advertising 320+ on a charge but who knows if that's realistic. And, will it be sold here? My local GM dealer says "no".

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The Bolt might do the job, once we see its EPA figures. GM is advertising 320+ on a charge but who knows if that's realistic. And, will it be sold here? My local GM dealer says "no".

No Canadian love form GM or Toyota. Just ship them across the border already!!! The Rave EV is built in Woodstock ON, but we can't buy in Canada???!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

    Chatbox
    You don't have permission to chat.
    Load More